[Validator] Hub-assigned validation tasks use node -e commands blocked by sandbox — 91% failure rate

[wangsheng520520]

Problem

Hub-assigned validation tasks frequently contain node -e validation commands (e.g., node -e 'if (1 + 1 !== 2) process.exit(1)'). These commands are hard-blocked by the evolver's sandbox safety gate (src/gep/validator/sandboxExecutor.js, anti-RCE control GHSA-jxh8-jh77-xh6g), which rejects node -e/-p/-r flags.

Result: the validator cannot execute these commands → failure_class: sandbox_block_node_flag → overall_ok: false → no credits earned.

Evidence

• Node: node_74c0d023894c
• Last 100 validation reports: 9 OK / 91 FAIL (9% success rate)
• Error: BLOCKED: validation command rejected by safety check (allowed prefix: node; shell operators prohibited; GHSA-jxh8-jh77-xh6g)
• Stake: 500 credits staked, earning ~0 return due to 91% failure rate
• The validator correctly classifies these as sandbox_block_node_flag (not exit_nonzero), so the Hub can distinguish sandbox incompatibility from real validation failures.

Root Cause

Many published assets use node -e '...' as their validation command. This was even the Hub's own recommended example in documentation. However, the evolver's sandbox (correctly) blocks inline eval as an anti-RCE measure. This creates a systemic incompatibility: any validator with sandbox enabled will fail these tasks.

Suggested Fixes

1. Hub-side publish gate: Reject or flag assets with node -e validation at publish time. The validation_cmd_unsandboxable error already exists — extend it to catch node -e/-p/-r patterns.
2. Provide a sandbox-safe validation template: e.g., node scripts/validate.js (script file form, the only shape the sandbox allows).
3. Update documentation: Remove node -e 'if (1 + 1 !== 2) process.exit(1)' from the recommended validation examples. Replace with a script-file-based example.

Local Workaround Applied

We repaired all 18 local genes that had node -e validation, replacing them with node scripts/gep-validate-noop.js (a sandbox-safe, zero-side-effect validation script). But Hub-assigned tasks from other nodes still use node -e, which we cannot fix locally.

Impact

• Validators with sandbox enabled earn ~0 credits despite active participation
• CPU/bandwidth consumed with no benefit
• Likely affects all evolver nodes running v1.85+ with default sandbox settings

[owenshen0907]

🤖 @bjw9808 这条 issue 在你负责的仓库,麻烦认领或跟进一下。(agent-control 自动提醒;未自动接入)